The AI SEO trap
With AI, anyone can improve their SEO today. That is exactly the problem: your competitors are doing it too, and the first page of Google still only has ten results. If all you do is keep up, you stay exactly where you were.
By Dries Nijs, Organic Web Specialist
Last updated: 20 November 2026
At a glance
The AI SEO trap: the short answer

The AI SEO trap is the belief that an AI assistant lets you handle your SEO yourself and that this will move you up in Google. The first part is true: your copy, titles and structure do get better. The second is not, because a position in Google is not a mark out of ten but a place in a queue. If everyone in the queue takes one step forward, everyone is still in the same place.
Moving up takes something your competitor cannot get from the same AI: figures about your market, choices about what you do and do not build, and someone who keeps measuring and adjusting.
The maths
Ten places, and the number is shrinking
A page of search results has ten regular places. AI has not changed that. What has changed: above those ten there is, more and more often, an AI answer from Google itself.
In two market studies from November 2026, such an AI answer appeared above 23 of the 40 keywords measured (dog breeders, the Netherlands) and above 65 of the 144 (garden machinery, the Netherlands). In my forecasts I count on roughly a third fewer clicks to the regular results for keywords like these.
More websites getting better, and fewer places to share out.
The trap
Why does almost no one move up when everyone gets better?
Ask the same AI the same question and you get roughly the same answer. You, and the four competitors in your region. You are all recommended the same keywords, the same structure and the same tips. The result: five websites that are all a bit better and all look alike.
Google still puts only one of them at the top. It picks the website that has something the other four do not.
The difference
So what does make the difference?
Three things your competitor cannot get from the same AI.
01
Figures about your market
An AI assistant estimates. A study measures: how many people search each month, who ranks now, how strong those websites are and what ChatGPT answers when someone asks about your service.
02
Choosing what not to build
For a webshop selling garden machinery I found a keyword with 27,100 searches a month. I dropped it: the shop had one product for it and the market is held by big brands. An AI does not make that choice for you, because it does not know your stock or your margin.
03
Keep measuring
Positions shift every week, because your competitors are not standing still either. If you optimise once and then stop, you slowly slip back. That is why SEO is long-term work, and why you have it checked by someone with experience. That is only normal: you do the same with your accounts and your boiler.
I use AI as a tool myself every day. The difference is not in the tool, but in what you have it do and who checks the result.
Examples
What such a study delivers: three examples
Three websites in three situations. The first two are forecasts from a study, the third was measured in Google Search Console. A forecast is a scenario, not a promise. The sample reports themselves are in Dutch.
Forecast
Existing website of a dog breeder
- Now: ±520
- Minimum: ±960
- Expected: ±2,690
- Maximum: ±6,170
Visitors per month from Google, after 12 months. Studied: 2,067 search queries in the Dutch market, with 187,000 purchase-oriented searches a month.
Forecast
New webshop with 60 blog articles
- Now: 0
- Cautious: ±1,400
- Realistic: ±2,800
- Upper limit: ±5,600
Visitors per month from Google, after 12 months. In the realistic scenario that is about 45 orders a month. Market: garden machinery, the Netherlands.
Measured
New website in the heating sector
- First impression in Google: 16 August 2026
- Twelve weeks later: 2,458 clicks in 28 days
- In the same 28 days: 21,910 impressions in AI answers
Not a forecast but a measurement. Source: Google Search Console, export of 9 November 2026. Market: Belgium.
Free for the first 28
What is your number?
Every market gives different figures. I only know yours once I have measured your website and your competitors.
I have been building for the web for 28 years. That is why I am making a free SEO and GEO report of their existing website for the first 28 people who ask. The normal price is € 250 excl. VAT. I make it myself, not with an automated scan, and you receive it from me personally in your inbox.
What is in the report?
- Where you stand now: your positions in Google and who ranks above you
- A technical check: what is holding your website back
- Your five biggest opportunities in Google
- What AI says about you, in ChatGPT and Perplexity
- A proposal for your site structure
- Your number: minimum, expected and maximum after 12 months
No obligation. You decide what you do with the report: carry it out yourself, hand it to your current web developer or discuss it with me. It is the same SEO and GEO analysis that costs € 250 on the pricing page.
Enter your web address below. You will receive your report in your inbox within 7 working days. No newsletter, no automated emails.
I only use your details to make and deliver your report. Read more in the privacy statement (in Dutch).
After your request
- I measure your website, your competitors and your visibility in AI answers
- I put the results and the three scenarios in a report
- You receive the report in your inbox within 7 working days
- You decide what you do with it
FAQ
Frequently asked questions about SEO with AI and the free report
Can I do my SEO myself with AI?
Partly, yes. Clear copy, logical pages and good titles are quicker to get right with it. The same goes for your competitors, which is why your position usually changes little. The difference lies in research, choices and follow-up.
Is the report really free?
Yes, for the first 28 people who ask. After that it costs € 250 excl. VAT. There is no subscription and no obligation attached.
How is it different from an SEO audit?
The report shows where you stand, where your opportunities lie and what that could deliver. An SEO audit goes further and examines what is holding your website back technically, with priorities and a walkthrough.
Do you guarantee a position in Google?
No. Nobody can, because Google and your competitors change every week. What I do: measure where you stand, show what is achievable and say honestly what it takes.
Further reading
The related service
SEO consultant
Research, technology and content, so that your website is found for the questions your customers search for.

About the author
Dries Nijs, Organic Web Specialist
I am Dries Nijs, a developer and SEO consultant from Maasmechelen. I have been building for the web since the 1990s and today use AI as a tool in my own work. MadeByDries is the personal brand under which I work.
Want to know what is in it for your website?
Request your free SEO and GEO report, or ask your question first. You will get a personal answer.